WIYN NCP spectroscopic survey meeting

US/Central
Description

Held in B343 Sterling Hall, UW - Madison

Zoom link:   https://uwmadison.zoom.us/j/7800277255  

Minutes

Analyses to consider

- Bias for HI rich/poor in redshift determination

  • John:  much easier to get redshifts for  galaxies with strong H emission lines   (could see to z 20)
  • check this!   Use HI mass to color relations used in Olivier's forecast paper
  • John could check part of this by looking at efficiency of finding z vs color

- What is the HI mass fraction for which we have the optical redshift? - Frank!

- Albert is plotting Reza's SDSS mocks in order to compare with our own survey

- Gabriela will run/refine her cluster-finding algorithm on Reza's mocks.  Hopefully, can comment on this in paper (unlikely to form a new paper)

- X-ray clusters.   Reza has checked ROSAT;   no confirmed clusters in our region.  (Sources in our region are identified as AGN.)

- Check SZ-filtered Planck maps for possible SZ detection - beyond scope of this paper

- ask Dan McCammon; Reza's new lab colleagues about e-Rosita x-ray clusters (possible future paper).   Dan will join us for dinner on Friday.

 

Writing/ editing tasks

- Note in introduction of paper

  • that other surveys have looked/are looking at NCP:     LOFAR, 21CMA
  • possibility of using catalog to find clusters

- use Durbala paper as example of a 'small' survey to follow for our own paper

- check cost of publishing in AJ  (Durbala is in AJ).  < $1K    (< 30 'quanta') - looks like Albert can pay this

- Paper writing/review/ integration of John's report

- Reza will insert John's text into draft paper;   refine organization of the paper first, then copy/paste pieces of John's document. 

 - All will carefully edit each section by assigned person below,  under 'supervision'.

2.  The Survey - John will supervise all of Section 2

2.1 Target Selection - Frank

2.2. Instrument Setup - Greg
2.3. Data Reduction - Greg


3. PRESENT THE CATALOG - Albert will supervise all of Section 3
3.1. Redshift distribution - Albert

3.2. Selection Function - Reza
3.3. Analyze structure present - Reza, Albert
3.4. Impact on future NCP surveys - Peter

There are minutes attached to this event. Show them.
    • 1
      Organization, Assignment of Tasks
    • 10:30
      Coffee Break at Aldo's
    • 12:30
      Lunch
    • 15:30
      Coffee Break at Aldo's
    • 17:30
      Dinner at Memorial Union Terrace
    • 2
      Resume paper discussion, writing/editing assignments
    • 10:30
      Coffee Break at Aldo's
    • 12:30
      Lunch at Union South
    • 17:30
      Dinner at Steenbocks on Orchard Street
    • 3
      Resume paper discussion
    • 10:00
      Move to 6242 Chamberlin Hall / Coffee Break at Aldo's
    • 4
      Resume paper discussion (In 6242 Chamberlin Hall)
    • 12:30
      Lunch
    • 5
      Return to B343 Sterling and Resume paper discussion
    • 18:00
      Dinner at Peter's House

      2012 Jefferson Street