Proton Accelerators for Science and Innovation Workshop

US/Central
Fermilab

Fermilab

Ken Long (Imperial College), Young-Kee Kim (FNAL)
Description
Research facilities driven by high-power proton beams have an impressive track record of promoting scientific and technological innovation to the direct benefit of the knowledge-based economy. The US has a track record of excellence in the provision of such facilities at both the energy and at the intensity frontiers. The UK also has an impressive track record, contributing at the intensity frontier. Both the UK and the US are key stakeholders of CERN which, with the recent closure of the FNAL Tevatron, is the world's energy-frontier laboratory for particle physics. Not only do advances in accelerator technology make it possible to conceive of entirely new accelerator facilities capable of expanding the horizons of the world's scientists, but, it is now possible to define the R&D path to the proton-accelerator based facilities that will revolutionise the health-care, clean-energy, and security agendas. R&D programmes designed to deliver the key technologies and systems are underway in both the UK and the US and, while communication, cooperation, and in some cases collaboration, between the various projects has been effective at an individual level, there is a great potential benefit in developing a more strategically-coordinated approach. Not only would greater cooperation substantially strengthen the domestic programmes, appropriate development of collaborative projects would allow the benefits to the science, health-care, energy, and security agendas to be delivered more rapidly. The "Proton accelerators for science and innovation" workshop that will be held at the Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory from the 12th to the 14th January 2012 will bring together the leading members of the user, developer, and 'consumer' communities from the UK and the US to review and discuss the issues outlined above. It is our ambition that this workshop will lay the foundations on which an appropriately coordinated programme for the development of the proton accelerators of the future can be built.
    • Plenary session: Introduction Curia II

      Curia II

      Fermilab

      • 10:30
        Registration and Coffee
      • 1
        Welcome
        Speaker: Robert Chatterton Dickson (UK Consul General)
      • 2
        Origin of meeting and meeting goals
        Speaker: Prof. Kenneth Long (Imperial College London)
        Slides
      • 3
        EMMA: Status and Prospects
        Speaker: Dr Shinji Machida (ASTeC STFC Rutherford Appleton Laboratory)
        Slides
    • 12:00
      Working Lunch
    • Plenary session: UK and US plans Curia II

      Curia II

      Fermilab

      • 4
        UK plans and goals
        Speaker: John Womersley (STFC)
        Slides
      • 5
        US plans and goals
        Speaker: Dr Pier Oddone (Fermilab)
        Slides
      • 6
        Discussion
    • 15:00
      Coffee break
    • Plenary session: Working group plans Curia II

      Curia II

      Fermilab

      • 7
        High-Power Targets and Machine Detector Interface
        Speaker: Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL)
        Slides
      • 8
        Applications of Proton Accelerators
        Speaker: Dr Yousry Gohar (Argonne National Laboratory)
      • 9
        High-power Proton Accelerators
        Speaker: Stephen Holmes (Fermilab)
        Slides
      • 10
        Muon Accelerators for Particle Physics
        Speaker: Dr Mark Palmer (Cornell University)
        Slides
      • 11
        RF and Magnets, Fast Acceleration
        Speaker: Jim Clarke
        Slides
      • 12
        Discussion
    • 18:00
      Wine and Cheese Reception South Crossover

      South Crossover

      Fermilab

    • Applications of Proton Accelerators Working Group: Accelerator driver sub-critical systems Snakepit (WH2NE)

      Snakepit (WH2NE)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Ken Peach (University of Oxford), Yousry Gohar
      • 13
        Introduction to thorium/sub critical reactors
        Speaker: Bob Cywinski
        Slides
      • 14
        Accelerator Challenges & ADSR work in the US
        Speaker: Dr Stuart Henderson (Fermilab)
        Slides
      • 15
        Accelerator Challenges & ADSR work in the UK
        Speaker: Hywel Owen
        Slides
      • 10:30
        Break
    • High Power Proton Accelerators: Introduction Curia II (WH2SW)

      Curia II (WH2SW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: John Thomason, Stephen Holmes (Fermilab)
      • 16
        Introduction
        Speakers: John Thomason, Stephen Holmes (Fermilab)
    • High Power Targets and Machine/Detector Interface Working Group: Introduction Blackhole (WH2NW)

      Blackhole (WH2NW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Chris Densham (Rutherford Lab), Prof. Jenny thomas (UCL), Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL), Dr Robert Tschirhart (Fermilab)
      • 17
        Introduction
        Speakers: Prof. Jenny thomas (UCL), Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL), Dr Robert Tschirhart (Fermilab)
        Slides
    • Muon Accelerators for Particle Physics Working Group: Introduction Theory East (WH3NE)

      Theory East (WH3NE)

      Fermilab

      • 18
        Opening and WG Guidance
        Speakers: Dr Jaroslaw Pasternak (Imperial College/RAF STFC), Dr Mark Palmer (Cornell University)
        Slides
    • RF and Magnets, Fast Acceleration Working Group Theory West (WH2NW)

      Theory West (WH2NW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Jim Clarke, Prof. Peter McIntyre (Texas A&M University)
      • 19
        Superconducting RF for Linear Hadron Accelerators
        Speaker: Mr Vyacheslav Yakovlev (FNAL)
        Slides
      • 20
        Superconducting RF Operational Experience at FNAL
        Speaker: Elvin Harms (Fermilab)
        Slides
      • 10:20
        Break
      • 21
        Advances in Proton Linac Design & Simulation
        Speaker: Dr Peter Ostroumov (Argonne National Laboratory)
        Slides
      • 22
        Superconducting Materials for SRF & High Field Magnets
        Speaker: Dr Lance Cooley (Fermilab)
        Slides
      • 23
        Prospects for Induction Acceleration in FFAGs
        Speaker: Neil Marks
        Slides
    • High Power Targets and Machine/Detector Interface Working Group: Review of High Power Proton Target Challenges Blackhole (WH2NW)

      Blackhole (WH2NW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Chris Densham, Prof. Jenny thomas (UCL), Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL), Dr Robert Tschirhart (Fermilab)
      • 24
        Thermo-mechanical Response (simulation and failure criteria)
        Speaker: Dr Tristan Davenne (RAL)
        Slides
      • 25
        Flowing Targets
        Speaker: Mr Bernie Riemer (ORNL SNS)
        Slides
      • 26
        Radiation Damage and Radiochemistry Issues
        Speakers: Dr Nikolaos Simos (BNL), Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL)
        Slides
      • 10:20
        Break
      • 27
        Facility Design
        Speaker: Mr Matt Fletcher (ISIS)
        Slides
      • 28
        Radiation Protection and Licensing
        Speaker: Dr Kamran Vaziri (FNAL)
        Slides
    • Muon Accelerators for Particle Physics Working Group: Near Term Accelerator Projects Theory East (WH3NE)

      Theory East (WH3NE)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Dr Jaroslaw Pasternak (Imperial College/RAF STFC), Dr Mark Palmer (Cornell University)
      • 29
        mu2e and g-2 at FNAL
        Speaker: Dr Eric Prebys (Fermilab)
        Slides
      • 30
        COMET
        Speaker: Yoshi Uchida
        Slides
    • High Power Proton Accelerators: Test Facilities Curia II (WH2SW)

      Curia II (WH2SW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: John Thomason, Stephen Holmes (Fermilab)
      • 31
        FETS Overview
        Speaker: Alan Letchford
        Slides
      • 32
        PXIE Test Facility
        Speaker: Sergei Nagaitsev (FNAL)
        Slides
      • 33
        Discussion
    • High Power Proton Accelerators: High Power Accelerators/Operational Experience and Upgrades Curia II (WH2SW)

      Curia II (WH2SW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: John Thomason, Stephen Holmes (Fermilab)
      • 34
        The ISIS Facility
        Speaker: John Thomason
        Slides
      • 35
        SNS
        Speaker: Mike Plum
        Slides
      • 36
        Discussion
      • 10:45
        Break
    • Muon Accelerators for Particle Physics Working Group: Intermediate Extensions to Current Capabilities Theory East (WH3NE)

      Theory East (WH3NE)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Dr Jaroslaw Pasternak (Imperial College/RAF STFC), Dr Mark Palmer (Cornell University)
      • 37
        VLENF
        Speaker: Prof. Alan Bross (Fermilab)
        Slides
      • 10:40
        Break
      • 38
        PRISM
        Speaker: Dr Jaroslaw Pasternak (Imperial College/RAF STFC)
        Slides
      • 39
        Next Generation mu2e and g-2 at FNAL
        Speaker: Dr Valeri Lebedev (Fermilab)
        Slides
    • Applications of Proton Accelerators Working Group: Medical Applications Snakepit (WH2NE)

      Snakepit (WH2NE)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Ken Peach (University of Oxford), Yousry Gohar
      • 40
        ADS Activity at Argonne National Laboratory
        Speaker: Dr Yousry Gohar (Argonne National Laboratory)
        Slides
      • 41
        Introduction to Proton Ion Beam therapy & Medical accelerator work in the UK
        Speaker: Ms Suzanne Sheehy (University of Oxford, John Adams Institute for Accelerator Science)
        Slides
      • 42
        Medical accelerator work in the US
        Speakers: Dr Carol Johnstone (Fermilab), Shane Koscielniak, TBD
        Slides
    • High Power Proton Accelerators: H- Source Development Curia II (WH2SW)

      Curia II (WH2SW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: John Thomason, Stephen Holmes (Fermilab)
      • 43
        H- Ion Source Development at RAL
        Speaker: Dan Faircloth
        Slides
      • 44
        H- Source Development at FNAL
        Speaker: Dan Bollinger (FNAL Proton Source Department)
        Slides
      • 45
        Discussion
    • High Power Targets and Machine/Detector Interface Working Group: Review of Requirements from the Experimental Programs Blackhole (WH2NW)

      Blackhole (WH2NW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Chris Densham, Prof. Jenny thomas (UCL), Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL), Dr Robert Tschirhart (Fermilab)
      • 46
        Overview
        Speakers: Prof. Jenny thomas (UCL), Dr Robert Tschirhart (Fermilab)
      • 47
        Neutrino (conventional)
        Speaker: Dr Phil Adamson (FNAL)
        Slides
      • 48
        PX - Kaon, Spallation, Muon
        Speaker: Prof. Mark Lancaster (UCL)
        Slides
      • 12:30
        Working Lunch
      • 49
        ISIS Upgrades
        Speakers: Dr David Findlay (ISIS), Mr Matt Fletcher (ISIS)
        Slides
      • 50
        Nu Factory and Muon Collider
        Speaker: Prof. Kirk McDonald (Princeton)
      • 51
        ADS
        Speaker: Dr Stuart Henderson (Fermilab)
        Slides
      • 52
        Other Application (medical/security)
        Speaker: Ken Peach (University of Oxford)
      • 15:30
        Break
    • High Power Proton Accelerators: Novel Approaches to High Power Proton Acceleration Curia II (WH2SW)

      Curia II (WH2SW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: John Thomason, Stephen Holmes (Fermilab)
      • 53
        Integrable Optics Test Accelerator
        Speaker: Alexander Valishev (Fermilab)
        Slides
      • 54
        Discussion (including Shinji Machida's talk 'The EMMA Experiment' from plenary session)
      • 12:30
        Working Lunch
    • Muon Accelerators for Particle Physics Working Group: Long Range Extensions of Capabilities Theory East (WH3NE)

      Theory East (WH3NE)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Dr Jaroslaw Pasternak (Imperial College/RAF STFC), Dr Mark Palmer (Cornell University)
      • 55
        IDS-NF
        Speaker: Mr Neil Bliss (STFC Daresbury Laboratory)
        Slides
      • 56
        Muon Collider Options
        Speaker: Steve Geer (FNAL)
        Slides
      • 13:00
        Working Lunch
    • Applications of Proton Accelerators Working Group Snakepit (WH2NE)

      Snakepit (WH2NE)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Ken Peach (University of Oxford), Yousry Gohar
      • 12:30
        Working Lunch
      • 57
        Discussion and Planning
        Slides
    • RF and Magnets, Fast Acceleration Working Group: RF & Fast Acceleration Theory West (WH2NW)

      Theory West (WH2NW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Jim Clarke, Prof. Peter McIntyre (Texas A&M University)
      • 12:50
        Working Lunch
      • 58
        High field dipole studies at FNAL
        Speaker: Dr Alexander Zlobin (Fermilab)
        Slides
      • 59
        Helical solenoids for muon colliders
        Speaker: Dr Michael Tartaglia (Fermilab Technical Division Magnet Systems Department Measurements and Analysis Group)
        Slides
      • 15:20
        Break
      • 60
        The use of HTS in HEP magnets
        Speaker: Emanuela Barzi (Fermilab)
        Slides
      • 61
        The PAMELA FFAG magnet designs
        Speaker: Holger Witte
        Slides
    • High Power Proton Accelerators: Supporting Technologies Curia II (WH2SW)

      Curia II (WH2SW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: John Thomason, Stephen Holmes (Fermilab)
      • 62
        Novel Diagnostics on FETS and ISIS
        Speaker: Jorgen Pozimski
        Slides
      • 63
        SRF Development at Fermilab
        Speaker: Robert Kephart kephart (FNAL)
        Slides
      • 64
        Discussion
    • Muon Accelerators for Particle Physics Working Group: Key Physics Demonstrations Theory East (WH3NE)

      Theory East (WH3NE)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Dr Jaroslaw Pasternak (Imperial College/RAF STFC), Dr Mark Palmer (Cornell University)
      • 65
        MICE 4D Cooling Program
        Speaker: Paul Soler
        Slides
      • 66
        EMMA FFAG Demonstration
        Speakers: Dr Jaroslaw Pasternak (Imperial College/RAF STFC), Dr Shinji Machida (ASTeC STFC Rutherford Appleton Laboratory)
        Slides
      • 67
        6D Cooling Options
        Speaker: Dr Robert B Palmer (Brookhaven National lab)
        Slides
      • 15:30
        Break
    • High Power Proton Accelerators: Future Facilities Curia II (WH2SW)

      Curia II (WH2SW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: John Thomason, Stephen Holmes (Fermilab)
      • 68
        Proton Driver Development at RAL
        Speaker: John Thomason
        Slides
      • 69
        Project X
        Speaker: Stephen Holmes (Fermilab)
        Slides
      • 70
        Discussion
    • High Power Proton Accelerators: Simulations Curia II (WH2SW)

      Curia II (WH2SW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: John Thomason, Stephen Holmes (Fermilab)
      • 71
        Code Development and Simulation Studies for High Power Machines
        Speaker: Dr Shinji Machida (ASTeC STFC Rutherford Appleton Laboratory)
        Slides
      • 72
        Simulation activities at Fermilab
        Speaker: Dr Vladimir Shiltsev (FNAL)
        Slides
      • 73
        Discussion
      • 15:45
        Break
    • High Power Targets and Machine/Detector Interface Working Group: Discussion of Intersection of Target Challenges and Program Requirements ("Matrix") Blackhole (WH2NW)

      Blackhole (WH2NW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Chris Densham, Prof. Jenny thomas (UCL), Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL), Dr Robert Tschirhart (Fermilab)
      • 74
        Overview of Matrix
        Speakers: Prof. Jenny thomas (UCL), Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL), Dr Robert Tschirhart (Fermilab)
      • 75
        Low Z Solid Targets (Neutrino, Kaon (?), Muon)
        Speakers: Prof. Jenny thomas (UCL), Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL), Dr Robert Tschirhart (Fermilab)
      • 76
        High Z Solid Targets (Spallation, NuFact(?))
        Speakers: Prof. Jenny thomas (UCL), Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL), Dr Robert Tschirhart (Fermilab)
      • 77
        Flowing� Targets (NuFact, Muon Collider, ADS)
        Speakers: Prof. Jenny thomas (UCL), Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL), Dr Robert Tschirhart (Fermilab)
    • High Power Proton Accelerators: Parallel Discussion Sessions Curia II (WH2SW)

      Curia II (WH2SW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: John Thomason, Stephen Holmes (Fermilab)
      • 78
        Parallel Discussion Sessions
    • Muon Accelerators for Particle Physics Working Group: Discussion Theory East (WH3NE)

      Theory East (WH3NE)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Dr Jaroslaw Pasternak (Imperial College/RAF STFC), Dr Mark Palmer (Cornell University)
      • 79
        Discussion and Planning
    • RF and Magnets, Fast Acceleration Working Group Theory West (WH2NW)

      Theory West (WH2NW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Jim Clarke, Prof. Peter McIntyre (Texas A&M University)
      • 80
        Discussion and Planning
    • High Power Targets and Machine/Detector Interface Working Group: Discussion of Collaborative Opportunities Blackhole (WH2NW)

      Blackhole (WH2NW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Chris Densham, Prof. Jenny thomas (UCL), Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL), Dr Robert Tschirhart (Fermilab)
      • 81
        Identification of Collaborative Opportunities
        Speakers: Prof. Jenny thomas (UCL), Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL), Dr Robert Tschirhart (Fermilab)
    • 18:00
      Working group dinner
    • High Power Proton Accelerators: Discussion of Collaborative Opportunities Curia II (WH2SW)

      Curia II (WH2SW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: John Thomason, Stephen Holmes (Fermilab)
      • 82
        Discussion of Collaborative Opportunites
      • 10:30
        Break
    • High Power Targets and Machine/Detector Interface Working Group: Discussion of Collaborative Opportunities (cont) Blackhole (WH2NW)

      Blackhole (WH2NW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Dr Chris Densham (Rutherford Appleton Laboratory), Prof. Jenny thomas (UCL), Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL), Dr Robert Tschirhart (Fermilab)
      • 83
        Identification of Collaborative Opportunities (con't)
        Speakers: Prof. Jenny thomas (UCL), Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL), Dr Robert Tschirhart (Fermilab)
        Slides
    • Muon Accelerators for Particle Physics Working Group Theory East (WH3NE)

      Theory East (WH3NE)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Dr Jaroslaw Pasternak (Imperial College/RAF STFC), Dr Mark Palmer (Cornell University)
      • 84
        Potential Synergies To Target in the US-UK Program
        Speaker: Dr Michael Zisman (Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory)
        Slides
      • 85
        Potential Synergies from the UK perspective- working title
        Speaker: Andrei Seryi (SLAC)
        Slides
      • 86
        Working Group Preliminary Summary for discussion and feedback
        Speakers: Dr Jaroslaw Pasternak (Imperial College/RAF STFC), Dr Mark Palmer (Cornell University)
      • 10:30
        Break
      • 87
        Discussion and Documentation of Collaborative Opportunities
    • RF and Magnets, Fast Acceleration Working Group Theory West (WH2NW)

      Theory West (WH2NW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Jim Clarke, Prof. Peter McIntyre (Texas A&M University)
      • 88
        800 MeV Strong-Focusing Cyclotron
        Speaker: Prof. Peter McIntyre (Texas A&M University)
        Slides
      • 89
        Identification of Potential Synergies
      • 10:30
        Break
      • 90
        Summary Writing and Documenting of Collaborative Opportunities
    • High Power Proton Accelerators: Preparation of Working Group Presentation Curia II (WH2SW)

      Curia II (WH2SW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: John Thomason, Stephen Holmes (Fermilab)
      • 91
        Preparation of Working Group Presentation
    • High Power Targets and Machine/Detector Interface Working Group: Summary Writing Blackhole (WH2NW)

      Blackhole (WH2NW)

      Fermilab

      Conveners: Dr Chris Densham (Rutherford Appleton Laboratory), Prof. Jenny thomas (UCL), Mr Patrick Hurh (FNAL), Dr Robert Tschirhart (Fermilab)
      • 92
        Writing Assignments
    • 12:30
      Working Lunch
    • Plenary session: working group reports Curia II

      Curia II

      Fermilab

      • 93
        High-power Targets and Machine Detector Interface
        Slides
      • 94
        Applications of Proton Accelerators
        Speaker: Hywel Owen
        Slides
      • 95
        High-power Proton Accelerators
        Speaker: Dr John Thomason (STFC)
        Slides
      • 96
        Muon Accelerators for Particle Physics
        Speaker: Dr Jaroslaw Pasternak (Imperial College/RAF STFC)
        Slides
      • 97
        RF and Magnets, Fast Acceleration
        Speaker: Jim Clarke
        Slides
      • 98
        Discussion
    • 15:30
      Coffee break
    • Plenary session: wrap-up Curia II

      Curia II

      Fermilab

      Closing plenary wrap-up of conclusions;
      Discussion of future workshops and topics

      • 99
        Wrap-up and Presentation of Conclusions
        Speaker: Young-Kee Kim (FNAL)
        Slides